Featured

Robert Plamondon’s Poultry and Rural Living

beth_feeding_small_barred_rock_pulletsI began writing up practical poultry tips on this website in 1997. Somebody had to!

When we moved back to Oregon in 1995, we soon started raising free-range chickens. There was little information on free-range poultry back then, and most of it was wrong. I embarked on a literature survey of the past 100 years, to find out what ideas and techniques worked and what didn’t. We put the more likely ones into practice, and also wrote them up here. You can’t find this stuff anywhere else.

I also wrote up related rural-living topics, such as living with a low-yield well and controlling rats and mice.

Day-old Black Sex-Link chicks and an Ohio heat-lamp brooder.
Day-old Black Sex-Link chicks and an Ohio heat-lamp brooder.

We raised grass-fed chickens, eggs, turkey, and pork on the farm using the same techniques shown here. My former sort-of monthly newsletter archives give some news about the what was going on and to-do lists for every month of the year.

Continue reading “Robert Plamondon’s Poultry and Rural Living”

Feed Supplements to Pasturage for Growth of Chickens

D. C. Kennard, L. E. Thatcher, AND V. D. Chamberlin
Ohio Experiment Station, March, 1949

Simple houses on free rangeGood range and pasturage offer the best opportunities for reducing feed costs in production of pullets for egg production and for the production of 4- to 6-pound chickens for marketing. How then can these opportunities be realized by poultry raisers to the fullest extent? What feed is necessary to supplement pasturage for satisfactory growth of chickens? To answer these questions, extensive experiments have been in progress during the past four years at the Ohio Agricultural Experiment Station.

What is Good Range and Pasturage?

Despite new information now available relative to nutritional requirements for the growth of chickens indoors, a good range which provides ample pasturage continues to be the most efficient and economical way for most poultrymen to raise pullets and chickens for marketing. The outdoor range provides well-recognized advantages, such as fresh air, direct exposure to sunshine, more exercise, and pasturage which includes succulent green feed, bugs, insects, worms, and the like. Moreover, the outside range can provide the necessary isolation of young chickens from older birds, which must always be considered as carriers. In fact, effective isolation (which can be realized by a suitable outside range) is often the prime factor in determining the success of the new crop of chickens each year. The pasturage may be edible grass and weeds, clover, alfalfa, or best of all, Ladino clover.

History of Three Range Rations

In early tests it was found that chickens which received free choice of whole grain and a 19 percent protein mash [that is, whole grain in one feeder and mash in another] when on a good range balanced their diet with protein at the rate of 14 percent of their total feed intake. It was from this basis that the Ohio Station’s special 14 percent protein, whole oats/mash range ration was derived. This proved a highly satisfactory ration and method of feeding chickens on range after the first 8 weeks. Being an all-in-one, whole oats/mash mixture, it was found preferable to the feeding of whole grain and mash separately. This ration with its greater protein and mineral content was found the most satisfactory for supplementing pasturage other than Ladino clover.

Then the question arose as to whether a 12 percent protein ration, with a saving of nearly half of the protein meals, might likewise meet the requirements for satisfactory growth of chickens having access to Ladino clover pasturage. The 12 percent protein ration did prove equally satisfactory.

The surprisingly good results secured from the 12-percent protein ration suggested that perhaps it was not the protein content but rather the mineral content that was mostly responsible for its success. If so, could similar results be secured from the use of corn, minerals, and Ladino clover? Seeking the answer to this question led to the discovery of the corn and minerals ration which appears to be the final answer to the question: What is the simplest feed necessary to supplement a good range and Ladino clover pasturage for the satisfactory growth of chickens? Thus, it proved to be the minerals which were the missing links responsible for the previous failure to secure satisfactory growth of chickens on Ladino clover pasturage when they received whole grain without mash.

This last named ration consisted of whole corn or wheat free-choice in one feeder and a second feeder containing a mash consisting of:

  • 90 pounds of coarsely ground corn,
  • 6 pounds of bone meal,
  • 2 pounds of oyster shell or limestone grit,
  • 2 pounds of granite or gravel grit, and
  • 2 pounds of salt.

Three Methods of Feeding Corn and Minerals

The corn and minerals ration may be fed by any of three different methods:

  1. the free choice of whole corn and a ground corn-minerals mash, as mentioned above;
  2. the free choice of whole corn in one feeder and the minerals (without ground corn) in another; and
  3. an all-mash mixture of coarsely ground corn and the minerals in a single feeder (without whole corn).

In an experiment with Leghorn pullets, little difference in body weight was evident among the three methods of feeding corn and minerals. There was, however, a lower (9 percent) feed consumption by the pullets that received whole corn and minerals in separate feeders, but this was not true with one test with R. I. Reds. More experiments will be necessary to establish the comparative merits of the three methods of feeding the corn and minerals ration. Until then, the feeding of whole corn and minerals in separate feeders may be considered questionable. This procedure has the further disadvantage of having to provide a special weather-proof feeder for the minerals. [RP: Presumably because the mineral mixture, unleavened by ground corn, turns into cement if it gets damp—Robert.]

Ladino Clover Versus Bluegrass and Farm Pasturage

Is Ladino clover necessary to secure the greatest benefits and economy from pasturage or may grass or run-of-farm range serve much the same purpose? This question is answered in four experiments involving 725 Leghorn and 2,250 R. I. Red pullets. Pullets on Ladino clover pasturage made a consistently faster rate of growth with less feed than did similar pullets on bluegrass or run-of-farm ranges. Leghorns on Ladino clover made 11 percent greater growth with 12 percent less feed than did pullets on bluegrass range. R. I. Red pullets made 9 percent faster growth with 1 2 percent less feed than did similar pullets on run-of-farm range.

In one test R. I. Red pullets receiving the 12-percent protein ration and Ladino clover made 17 percent more growth than did similar pullets on run-of-farm range that received the 14-percent protein ration. Feed consumption of both groups was much the same.

The faster rate of growth of pullets on Ladino clover pasturage with approximately 12 percent less feed indicates the distinct advantage and economy in raising chickens on a range of Ladino clover. Ladino clover, with its greater protein content and greater palatability throughout the growing season, permits the successful use of the 12 percent protein ration or the corn and minerals ration. These rations, with Ladino clover, enable the poultryman to realize greatest economy in raising his chickens on good range and pasturage.

FAQ: Chicken Myths and Scams

There are a lot of myths and a few scams in the poultry world, and I thought I’d take a swing at some of them.

I’ve heard that long eggs hatch into roosters and short eggs hatch into hens. Is this right?

Ah, the appeal of phallic symbolism! Sigmund Freud would have something to say about this. Nope, sometimes a cigar-shaped egg is just a cigar-shaped egg. Too bad: everyone would love to be able to do a gender reveal before putting the egg into the incubator.

Aren’t there hormones in poultry meat and eggs?

If this were 1948, maybe. Today? No. Using hormones to boost egg production was a brief fad in the Forties, but was abandoned because it didn’t work. Using hormones to produce soft-meated roasters lasted into the 1950s, but the improved growth rates of normal, untreated broilers made the practice irrelevant–the broilers got as big as anyone wanted without chemicals.

The only hormone that was ever used in any quantity on poultry (DES) was banned in 1959, and everyone but a few die-hard farmers had given up hormones by then, anyway. Hormones are now illegal in poultry and eggs.

The people who advertise “No hormones” are either fear-mongers, or ignorant, or both. The USDA won’t let you put “no hormones” on inspected eggs or poultry because they’re awfully tired of this scam.

Is it true that the eggs in the stores are six months old?

If this were 1909, maybe, but only in fall and winter. In the bad old days, the hens laid mostly in the spring, and practically stopped in the fall and winter. The only way stores could have a decent supply of eggs year-round was to buy them in the spring and refrigerate them until fall. I’ve republished Milo Hastings’ fascinating 1909 book, The Dollar Hen, which goes into this (and every other aspect of the egg industry) with his usual fascinating thoroughness.

This was a lot better than nothing, but long-term humidity-controlled refrigeration costs a lot of money, and every day the eggs are stored, they lose a little quality. In the old cold-storage business, you put them in as Grade AA-quality in the spring. When you took them out in the fall, they’d be Grade B quality if you were lucky.

These days, the average commercial hen lays about three times as many eggs as in 1920, and production is hardly seasonal at all, what with artificial lighting and controlled-environment housing. My farm has problems with seasonal production because my hens go outdoors in all weather every day of the year, but it’s different with modern confinement housing.

In any event, you can’t sell Grade B eggs anymore (consumers refuse to buy them), and eggs under USDA inspection (which includes all the giant producers) must have a sell-by date of 30 days or less. So there isn’t a cold-storage egg industry anymore. Instead, all eggs that are hard to sell because of grade or age are turned into “liquid egg product” and used by bakeries, restaurants, and the processed food industry. Liquid egg product can be frozen indefinitely, and this allows any lingering seasonality or bumps in supply and demand to be absorbed.

Don’t they put all sorts of yucky horrible stuff in chicken feed?

It depends on your threshold of yuck, but not usually. You can easily ruin the productivity of a flock by forcing them to eat things they don’t like or that aren’t good for them. Maintaining high production requires quality feed.

If you’re interesting in feed formulation, look at Feeding Poultry, which I have republished. It has everything.

As with most pet and livestock foods, it’s a good idea to taste chicken feed yourself. I’d switch suppliers if I ever ran into off-flavors (like burned, rancid, or other yucky tastes). In my experience as an amateur chicken-feed taste tester, it has always tasted wholesome, though bland, very bland. It would make a great cereal for particularly ascetic health-food types.

The bulk of just about every chicken ration consists of corn and soybeans, with other ingredients playing only a minor part.

This is not to say that there are never disgusting ingredients in chicken feed, because sometimes there are.

The most unpleasant ingredient is chickens. “Spent Hen Meal” consists of whole hens, ground, steamed, and dried. While such an ingredient obviously contains all the nutrients necessary to make a hen, and the use of spent hen meal has been proven through long use to be safe, the concept is pretty offensive. You won’t see spent hen meal in the feed you buy at the feed store; it seems to be used only by large egg producers who have absolutely no market for their old hens. You can’t even sell them for soup or dog food anymore, because “broiler breeders” — the hens that lay the eggs that broiler hatch from — are dirt-cheap and have better carcass quality.

Beef scrap and beef tallow are often added to chicken feed. Beef scrap is all the pieces with meat on them left over after butchering cattle; ground up, steamed, and dried. This can make a very good ingredient for chicken feed (though its quality varies widely and some parts of the carcass have little nutritional value, but it isn’t used as much as it used to be because the pet-food industry uses up most of it, so it’s expensive. Beef tallow is just the rendered fat. This is also an excellent feed ingredient.

Some people object to these ingredients in chicken feed, but I’ve never seen anything wrong with them as a general thing. However, in the specific case of my farm, I avoid  beef scrap, because my goats and sheep sometimes get into the chicken feed, and I don’t want them getting any beef scrap, because if they did, I wouldn’t be doing my part to keep the U.S. BSE-free.

Is it true that a lot of “free-range” eggs are from birds that are really being raised in confinement?

Yep, it’s true, all right. All the “official” free-range systems that I’ve come across are scams, at least by my standards. This includes both the totally unconvincing U.S. free-range egg producers, and the “Let’s give our scam a governmental seal of approval” EU system.

My test for a free-range system being “real” goes like this: If you moved all the feeders and waterers outside, would any chickens die of hunger or thirst? Obviously, in a true free-range system, where all the chickens wander in and out of the building all day, it doesn’t really matter if the feeders and waterers are indoor or outdoors. They’ll be fine either way.

But in fake free range, the goal is to run a factory-farm operation while getting a price premium for the “free-range” label.

In the EU, you have to maintain a green yard for the chickens to use, but if you put more than, say, fifty hens on an acre of turf, the grass will be destroyed in no time. So the producers discourage the chickens from going outside, through the use of doors that are too few or too small, and by other methods. If only a handful of chickens actually go outside, you’ve really got a confinement operation, and you can run it like any other factory farm.

Here’s how you do this: Chickens can recognize about 100 other chickens, and hang out with the ones they know. If they have to go past a lot of strangers to get outside, they won’t go outside. So all it takes is a long walk past other chickens, and they’ll never even try to go out the door. Given the immense size of modern chicken houses, this problem is almost insurmountable. You have to use more and smaller houses if you want to do it right. This, plus the other sources of increased labor in real free range, makes real free-range eggs very expensive to produce.

The same situation is true to an even larger degree with free-range broilers, since meat birds have been bred for lethargy and are far less willing to trek long distances to reach an outside door.

Is it important to protect my chickens from drafts?

No, that’s a myth, based on the 19th-century notion that drafts cause colds. The concept is pretty much meaningless. True, chickens need to be protected from hypothermia, so you wouldn’t want to (for example) leave them outdoors, soaking wet, in sub-zero weather. But creating a tightly sealed chicken house to “eliminate drafts” is very unhealthy for the chickens, even in cold climates.

In fact, doing the opposite is infinitely better. I’ve republished Fresh-Air Poultry Houses, which will show you the ropes. Also see my housing FAQ for more info.

Baby chicks, of course, need to be kept warm, so limiting the wind-chill factor in cold weather is important. But that’s not about “drafts,” it’s about warmth.

Is it important to use standard-bred birds?

Not unless that’s what you like. The idea that purebred chickens are better than “mongrelized” chickens (based on crosses) is based on Nineteenth-Century racial theories, and was thoroughly discredited a hundred years ago.

Commercial chickens are far more productive than purebred chickens. I’ve republished the 1916 Poultry Breeding and Management by James Dryden, the first person to prove that egg production can be improved by selective breeding. He also demonstrated that crosses can achieve this better than purebreds. (And the book was so practical that it was highly valued even by farmers who weren’t interested in the breeding sections.)

The purebreds can better-looking, though: many breeds are beautiful and delightful. And breeding for competition is a fascinating hobby. But if your requirements are practical, commercial strains are better.

Don’t old-fashioned chickens do better in a small-farm environment?

I used to think this, too! But when I put it to the test, the commercial breeds ran rings around the heritage breeds. Commercial White Leghorns are very active foragers on free range in addition to being productive. Commercial brown-egg birds are much the same. I’m not even convinced that the heavily feathered standard breeds have higher winter production than the commercial chickens. They lay so many fewer eggs to start with that extra-thick feathers aren’t enough to even up the score.

With meat birds, it’s even more of a walkover. Standard-breed chickens will give you a two-pound dressed carcass at twelve weeks if you’re lucky. A modern broiler will give you a four-pound carcass at seven weeks.

FAQ: Egg Eating

My Hens are Eating Eggs. What Should I Do?

All hens eat broken eggs when they can.  Chickens are unsentimental (in addition to being unintelligent), and to them a broken egg has no significance beyond being free food.  Hens do not normally consider unbroken eggs to be edible, but if they have anything stuck to them, such as smears of yolk from another egg, they’ll peck at that.  Sometime they learn to break eggs on purpose this way.

Hens keep an eye on each other, and when one finds food, others crowd in.  In this way, egg-eating can spread through a flock.

There are a lot of old wive’s tales about egg-eating.  One claims that if you blow an egg and refill it with cayenne pepper, the pain of the hot condiment will cure a hen of egg-eating.  This doesn’t work; birds don’t react to peppers the way people (and other mammals) do. They think it tastes just great.

Another concept is that egg-eating happens because there are one or two ringleaders, and if you remove these from the flock, the egg-eating will stop.

Both my own experience and the research papers I’ve read indicate that egg-eating generally starts up when conditions favor it, and it dies down when conditions don’t favor it, regardless of whether you isolate “ringleaders” or not. In short, it’s up to you.

To reduce egg-eating, you should:

  1. Provide darkened nests.  Hens do not like to eat in the dark, and they are less active in the dark.  They’ll break fewer eggs moving around in the nest boxes, and if they do break one, they’re less likely to eat it (and all the surrounding yolk-smeared eggs).  Nests can be darkened by putting flaps over the front and by installing them in a dim area, such as at the back of the house. Having a separate (darkened)  nesting house or nesting room also helps.
  2. Use colony nests.  These are essentially big nest boxes two feet by four feet by about 18″ high, with a small door about eight inches square.  In ordinary nest boxes, two or three hens will often jam themselves into a nest meant for one, even if empty nests are available, and this breaks a lot of eggs.  Roomier nests lead to less breakage, and colony nests are very dark inside.  These are often set directly on the floor in a dark part of the henhouse.  They should be ventilated (making a couple of walls out of pegboard is good). Use one for every 40-50 hens.  A variant is the tunnel nest, which is two feet wide and eight feet long, with a door at each end.  Use one for every 80-100 hens.
  3. Use deeper litter. Many nests have a front board only 4″ high to hold the litter in.  Doubling the height of the board will prevent the litter from being scratched out of the nest so quickly, and fewer eggs will be broken.  I find that a mixture of straw and wood shavings makes a good litter. I add straw about half the time and shavings about half the time, and it evens out. (Throw out the litter when it gets dirty.)
  4.  Collect eggs frequently. If I collect my eggs on time, twice a day, I have little trouble with egg-eating. If I’m away and collect them only in the evening, I lose some eggs, mostly from the nest boxes that least resemble the advice in suggestions 1-3 above.
  1. Don’t use screwy rations.  Deficiencies in vitamin D, calcium, phosphorus, or biotin can lead to thin-shelled eggs and rickets. The feed recipes people invent for themselves without reading poultry nutrition textbooks tend to be deficient in one or all of these. By feeding a balanced poultry ration with a feeder of oyster shell on the side (for supplemental calcium), you will avoid a lot of trouble.
  2.  Don’t crowd the nests. If you’re using ordinary compartmentalized nest boxes, provide one nest for every four hens.

FAQ: Chickens and Animal Welfare

What’s all this I hear about inhumane treatment of chickens?

You’ll get two sets of answers: one from the people who have worked with large numbers of chickens, and another from those who haven’t.

The experienced folks like real animal welfare. Healthy, alert, contented chickens are fun to be around, easy to manage, and sometimes even profitable. Stressed or ailing chickens are none of these things. Anything that stresses or distresses  your chickens can lead to the nightmarish problems related to bad management: disease, stunted growth, the need for endless hours applying corrective measures, the death of the chickens, and the failure of the farm.

Having healthy, happy, non-stressed-out chickens is important, and doing this well is endlessly fascinating, since there’s always more to learn. There are a lot of other people interested in this, and the experiences of farmers and the scientists at the agricultural experiment stations (past and present), have been an enormous help to me. I’m not the only one.

Keeping chickens isn’t rocket science, but there are some things you need to know if you’re going to do it well. I wrote my book, Success With Baby Chicks, because, I had disappointing and even heartbreaking results at first, and this was more typical than it should have been. After surveying the poultry books, magazines, and experiment station bulletins of the past hundred years, I discovered a fund of ideas and techniques that work very well in small-flock settings, and my results have been much better ever since. Many of these techniques were no longer general knowledge, so it was time for a book. It’s helped thousands of poultrykeepers do a better job raising chicks. Hardly any of the chicks die, they’re healthier, and everything works better in general.

What’s odd about this whole process was that I never found anything from the animal welfare groups to be of any use. Taking care of chickens is a matter of understanding them, learning how to spot trouble almost before it happens, and recognizing that the dangers to your creatures are many, varied, and come from every quarter: leaking automatic waterers, rats tunneling into the brooder house, children who don’t know how to behave around them, and so on. Chickens can become frightened if you simply walk past them with  an empty feed sack without rolling it up first; it makes you look big and scary. It’s mostly a matter of observation and careful, thoughtful attention, and experience. It’s not an armchair thing.

What I see from the animal welfare groups isn’t like this. It’s more like yearning for farms to really be what they were in the Little Golden Books that were read to them as children. I’m a big fan of the inner child, but you can’t skip the intermediate steps when putting things into practice. Planet Reality has too way much gravity.

Milo Hastings, who understood this a century ago, said in The Dollar Hen (1909):


Combination and specialization so commonly cut down expenses because of larger operations and the use of better tools, that we may take this saving for granted. When it comes to labor there is a different story. The manual laborer working with boss and gang or the machine-tender in the factory work as well or better for large than small concerns, but the labor of a poultry plant is different. It is made up of a great many different operations well scattered in space and time. For the most part it is simple labor, but it is essential that it be performed with reasonable concern for the welfare of the business.

In other industries, as with men working at a bench, the presence of a foreman keeps them busy and their work may be daily inspected. To have foremen in poultry work would require as many foremen as laborers, and even then they would be useless, for when the last round of the brooder is made at night, a foreman standing three feet away could not know whether the laborer who had placed his hand in the brooder had found all well or all wrong…

The bulk of labor in poultry work must be self-reliant labor and the only test for such efficiency is number of chicks reared and the weight of the egg basket.


Education and experience are the real keys to raising happy, healthy livestock. The agricultural extension service was a brilliant innovation. At the experiment stations, the agricultural scientists try different techniques to see what really works in practice under local conditions, then write it up and share it with anyone who’s interested. Untested opinions about how things ought to work go onto the “to be tested” list and aren’t repeated with the same conviction. Why would they be? The world needs more of this.

Aren’t Laying Cages Bad?

Big Dutchman laying cages.

Laying cages are chicken jails. “Cage-free” floor operations are a chicken concentration camps.

Personally, I don’t like cages, but I don’t like indoor confinement, either. A laying cage is a chicken jail; a cageless floor confinement operation is a chicken concentration camp. Being for one and against the other is ridiculous, even concerning.

A breeding flock in high-density floor confinement. (Nutri-News Magazine.)

The one thing you can say for certain is that cage operations look uglier close up. If you’re superficial, that matters. Otherwise, not so much.

The vast majority of laying hens in the U.S. are kept in laying cages, and have been since around 1960, though laying cages themselves were developed in the 1930s by farmers.

People like the myth that laying cages were invented by Evil Conglomerates, but that’s a fairy tale. They were around before the conglomerates were a gleam in a businessman’s eye.

Our national folklore assumes that farmers were honest and virtuous until chemical and industrial farming  were introduced, at which point they became evil, or at least stupid.

But we’re talking about the same farmers! A whole generation of farmers had one foot in each world. So anytime you want to know what the deal was—why farmers who started out with old-time methods made the switch, and what they liked and disliked about it—you only have to read farm publications between, say, 1945 and 1965. It’s all right there, especially in farm magazines and their letter sections.

The merits of different variations of the old vs. the new were endlessly tested and debated. We ended up with laying cages because floor confinement sucks even more.

What about genuine, bona fide free range? It has a vastly higher production cost per egg, and even then can’t be done meaningfully year-round in many climates. So it’s limited geographically and by how many people are willing to pay far more for a premium product.

Historically, the consensus has been that laying cages can be an excellent management system if you use them well. I remember reading in a 1959 or 1960 issue of “Egg Producer” that long-time egg farmers, who loved being chicken farmers and took excellent care of their chickens, sometimes preferred one and sometimes the other. Many others found little difference until they went away on vacation. The substitutes who tended the farm did better with cage operations, without the stumbling from one minor disaster to another that often occurred with floor operations.

The poultry scientists of the day had similar experiences and worked with innumerable farmers trying things from different angles. That’s why I tend to publish books from this period, such as the thorough and excellent Poultry Production by Leslie E. Card, written by poultry scientists who’d been around the block and knew all there was to know about the old, the new, and mixes of both.

So, to answer your question, many thousands of farmers with decades of experience with cage-free operations, who liked working with chickens and were good at it, switched to cages in the Fifties and Sixties and found them perfectly satisfactory. The implication of the vacation experiences is that people without decades of experience would have a less painful time learning how to run a cage operation, and would likely do a better job overall. And it’s better for the chickens when the farmer does a good job.

Typical morning on my farm.

Keep in mind that my own commercial laying flock consists of an almost ludicrously low-density and largely outdoor free-range operation. I have no reason to go to bat for cage confinement, other than a pesky regard for the truth.

Anyway, there are cages and cages. “Colony cages” are supposed to be the best, according to people who are really good at keeping chickens (I don’t know about anyone else). These are bigger cages with a flock of, say, 12 hens, and have a perch to roost on and a nest box to lay in. Chickens like nest boxes and perches. Standard cages have neither. For that matter, high-density floor confinement generally has nest boxes but no perches. A colony cage has a social organization that’s a good match for a hen’s social instincts —chickens seem to like being in a flock of about this size.

Standard laying cages have 1-3 chickens (too small for a proper pecking order), while high-density floor confinement has thousands or tens of thousands of chickens in one enormous room. A chicken can recognize about 100 other chickens and doesn’t like to be surrounded by strangers. This means that even in “open” floor confinement, the hens don’t move around much because of all the strangers. They stay close to the chickens they know. It’s like being in a cage with invisible walls.

The methods often proposed as “humane,” such as high-density free-range, have too high a density for the chickens to really exhibit their normal social behavior. Also, the stocking density of the “range” (up to 400 hens per acre) is insane: the only way to keep grass growing on the range is to prevent more than a handful hens from ever going outside while pretending not to be doing any such thing. This has apparently been raised to an art form in the EU.

The alternative is to ignore the grass and promote a barren yard as a plus, which it isn’t, and promoting “outdoor access” as a plus instead of a minus. Barren yards are bad for the hens. Among other things, manure and pathogens build up in the untended ground far worse than they do in the litter or slatted floors indoors.

Seriously, the whole thing is basically a scam whose purpose (from the producer’s point of view) is to allow factory-farmed eggs to be sold at premium prices. God knows what the consumer gets out of it. A cut-rate feeling of smugness and virtue, I suppose. Not high-quality eggs or any fact-based reason to presume that the hens are happy, that’s for sure.

“Neither a sucker nor a charlatan be.” — Polonius, probably.

Cages, on the other hand, give some immunity to disease and parasites, because the birds are separated from each other and because their manure falls through the floor of the cage, which eliminates manure-related health problems. The chickens have little opportunity panic and smother each other, even in the larger colony cages, and lots of things can panic a flock of chickens. You won’t get the same level of wholesale cannibalism because it’s a contagious behavior and the separation prevents that. Some of the fancier techniques, like the use of conveyor belts under the cages to take the manure away, maintain a better level of air quality in the chicken house.

All in all, I think that high-density cage confinement is safer for the hens and easier for the farmer to learn how to do well than “cage-free” confinement. Not that I’d care to do either one myself.

What about debeaking? I hear that the chickens can’t even eat after their beaks have been cut off!

A beak-trimmed hen. Courtesy Thegreenj and Wikimedia Commons.

If you can get a chicken to lay hundreds of eggs without eating anything, you’re going to be rich!

Beak-trimming is done to prevent cannibalism, which can be a real problem in confinement operations. Death is not something that anyone interested in animal welfare (and not just cosmetics) can possibly ignore.

We don’t do beak-trimming on our farm because it’s not necessary and it’s a pain in the ass. You generally don’t see cannibalism except in confined chickens, and ours have free range. (One of the reasons you can tell that the so-called “free range” in the EU is fake is that the farmers have to beak-trim their hens.)

When comparing the beak-trimmed chickens we have bought from various sources (usually the Poultry Science Department at Oregon State University) with non-beak-trimmed chickens, they all behave exactly the same, even when mixed together in the same flock. If beak-trimming is supposed to make the hen’s life a misery, no one has told the hens.

The real issue with beak-trimming, from the farmer’s point of view, is that it’s a laborious, disgusting job. The machine that cuts and cauterizes the beak works pretty well, but the smell is horrendous! But it’s a lot better than an outbreak of cannibalism. Anything is better than an outbreak of cannibalism.

Modern broilers have had the tendency towards cannibalism bred out of them. Some commercial layer strains are much less cannibalistic than others. I try to buy non-cannibalistic strains so my layer chicks don’t kill each other in the brooder house, before they go out on pasture. So far, no one has succeeded in coming up with a profitable layer strain that is sufficiently non-cannibalistic throughout a life in confinement that beak-trimming is unnecessary. It seems like a good idea, though.

It is perfectly possible to keep a flock of laying hens in confinement without performing beak-trimming. You just need to get higher egg prices to pay for the expense of having more dead and injured hens due to cannibalism. You can even brag about your “animal welfare” if you want. People do this. But it seems negligent to me.

What About Forced Molting?

Modern hens keep laying and laying and laying, but after about a year of laying both the shell quality and the interior quality of the eggs starts to plummet. The hen needs to stop laying, take a rest, and lose some weight. If she does this, she’s good for another year of profitable laying.

To make the hen stop laying and lose weight, you have to put her on a diet. You can do it the fast way or the slow way. The industry uses the fast way, usually removing all food for up to ten days, and often removing water for the first three days. The water removal is to stress her hard enough to make her stop laying immediately. Otherwise, she’ll pour her body reserves into additional eggs first. Among other things, this embrittles her bones. They say it’s no kindness to hang a man slowly, and the same probably applies to hens and molting.

I never bother with forced molting. My hens have an outdoor lifestyle and the stress is provided by colder weather, shorter days, and increasing rain. All my feeders are outdoors, so the hens get rained on. Whether subjecting hens to six months of Oregon rains at mealtimes is more “humane” than subjecting them to a ten-day molting program, I have no idea. How do you measure such things?

In Europe, they don’t force-molt hens. They kill them after the first laying year. They say it’s more humane! I am not making this up. And don’t get me started on the kind of killing machines they think are “humane.” It really creeps me out.

Molting involves growing a new set of feathers as well as going on a diet and taking a vacation from egg-laying, and hens who have lost a lot of their feathers are unattractive, which is apparently a death sentence in some people’s minds.

Is dust-bathing important to the hens?

I don’t know. The emphasis on dust-bathing is mostly a marketing gimmick used by people with high-density floor operations trying to make their stuff sound better than cages. It’s not practical to put a dust bath in a cage operation, but in a floor operation the hens will dust-bathe in whatever’s on the floor (dirt, wood shavings, dried manure, whatever).

Chickens like dust-bathing, but whether it bums them out to not be able to (assuming they don’t have any lice that render it important), I have no idea.

We experimented with dust baths from time to time, using different traditional materials like wood ashes. In the winter, it’s too hard to keep a dust bath dry enough to be useful in the Oregon winter, and hens can find plenty of dust on their own in the summer. I have nothing definite to report except that hens don’t react strongly to the arrival of dust bath. Not like they do to the arrival of a pan of oyster shell when they’ve gone without for a day or two.

How do you approach animal welfare?

I think of it as a Venn diagram with three circles:

  1. What does the chicken like?
  2. What do I like?
  3. Profit

The overlap of all three is the place to be. I want to have a pleasant, rewarding time dealing with my chickens. Having the chickens be content is necessary to my having a pleasant time. It’s also a basic requirement of good husbandry, and makes management easier. Making money is important to the non-hobbyist as well. Sustainable agriculture has to sustain the farmer.

Chickens are easy to please, especially in a low-density free-range operation like mine, so making them happy is mostly a matter of eliminating negatives and maintaining a good level of care.

I’ve discovered that chickens are terrified of being chased around, while their reactions to injury or the misfortunes of flock mates are much more muted than you’d expect. The first time a dog chased my flock, they were visibly upset for days, even though none of them had been hurt. But we had some pigs who learned that they could simply stand still and hens would wander too close, to be killed with a single snap of the jaws. The rest of the flock was not upset. They saw their flock mate die, but it had little effect on them.

So chickens aren’t very smart, and react more to appearances than outcomes. Just like people!

I don’t think chickens have any concept of death. Treat them gently, don’t startle them, and don’t let anything chase them, and they’ll be a lot happier. I hate it when kids chase chickens around.

The field of ethology, which studies what animals actually like and how they actually behave (as opposed to treating them like little humans in chicken suits) has turned up interesting information that’s worth knowing. For example, hens don’t like roosters much, but they have a strong desire to lay their eggs in a secluded nest. Paying attention to the chicken’s preferences is good husbandry.

In general, I have found that publications about farming—any aspect of farming—are wildly inaccurate unless they are written by and for farmers. Armchair experts don’t know what they’re talking about. On the other hand, I’ve found farmer-oriented how-to publications much more useful, often containing real wisdom.

But the most important thing you can do is to stop being such a cheapskate. My eggs cost $5.00 a dozen locally, and if I shipped them into big-city stores, they’d cost at least $10 a dozen. If you’re paying less than that, you’re either not getting the real thing, or you’re getting it from a farmer who is doing it as a hobby, not as a real business.

Low-density poultry is very labor-intensive. People deserve to get paid. The reality is that factory farming works. It provides products very cheaply. You can’t get away from factory-farming by paying a price premium of 10%, or 50%, or even 100%. The real deal is going to cost you about five times as much. Most people don’t care anywhere near that much, and will be happy to settle for factory-farm products that pretend to be something else. And as long as consumers are willing to settle for Potemkin farms, the real thing can’t happen, except as a niche product.

FAQ: Health Issues

They can’t be super chickens all time time. Sometimes our chickens have health troubles, like the ones covered here.

Chickens Attacking and Even Killing Each Other

The tendency to cannibalism and feather picking varies widely among different breeds and strains of chickens. Next time, ask your hatchery to recommend a non-cannibalistic strain before placing your order.

Commercial flocks generally use beak-trimming to reduce the birds’ ability to harm one another. This frees the breeders of commercial strains from any need to control cannibalism. Still, there are non-cannibalistic strains out there. My experience with the white-egg California Grays from Hoover Hatchery are quite non-cannibalistic. Some brown-egg hybrid layers are, too, but they go by overlapping names.

As mentioned above, beak-trimming controls cannibalism. Day-old chicks can have their beaks trimmed at the hatchery, but this is temporary and has to be done again around six weeks or so. I’ve never seen an outbreak before six weeks, so I don’t see the point. Beak-trimming is unaesthetic, sure, but nothing is more horrifying than a flock of actively cannibalistic birds. Trust me on this.

Crowding increases cannibalism. Inadequate feeder and waterer space increases cannibalism. Malnutrition increases cannibalism. Feeding pellets instead of mash increases cannibalism. Keeping the chickens on wire floors instead of on litter increases cannibalism. Using sand instead of straw or wood shavings as litter increases cannibalism.

Low light levels can eliminate cannibalism. Birds become relatively inactive in dim light.

Giving the birds access to green free range usually prevents cannibalism and can stop an active outbreak in its tracks. I have tried this several times, and it has always worked like magic. (I don’t know if it works with barren yards. I doubt it.)

The Wisconsin Experiment Station developed a “salt cure” in 1942 that is supposed to be 99% effective. For a single morning, replace the birds’ usual water with water that has one tablespoon of salt added per gallon. Replace the salt water with fresh water in the afternoon. Repeat three days later.

Adding palatable, high-fiber feeds will discourage feather-picking. Whole or rolled oats, alfalfa hay, and alfalfa meal help prevent cannibalism from starting but probably won’t stop it.

Given the birds access to green range will of course provide vast quantities of palatable, high-fiber feeds, while also reducing crowding and increasing the vitamin content and maybe the protein level of the diet.

Sometimes flocks of pullets that are given free-choice grain will eat too much grain and become cannibalistic. I suspect that this is only true for confined flocks, and only for brief periods, especially when they first start to lay. At the first sign of cannibalism, cease feeding grain except maybe for moderate amounts of oats.

Some poultry supply houses (such as Kuhl) sell “peepers” — blinders for turkeys, pheasants, and maybe chickens. This makes it hard for them to take aim at potential victims. Peepers are removable. I haven’t tried them myself.

Many people swear by the “pine tar” method for birds that have had their tail feathers pulled out. Slather some pine tar (available at feed stores and garden supply stores) on the bare skin where the chicken is being pecked. It hides the red wound and perhaps tastes bad enough that pecking loses its appeal.

Roost Mites

Roost mites are little eight-legged bugs that hide during the day and swarm over your hens at night. They can kill your chickens — they’ve killed some of mine. Before feeding, they’re gray; after feeding, they’re red with your chickens’ blood. They seem to be everywhere in North America; I don’t know about other continents.

Roost mites breed very quickly in warm weather. During the day, they hide in cracks and crevices, and in litter. When they’re engorged with blood, they’re fragile; they can pop like balloons. If you start noticing eggs with little pinhead-sized red or brown dots on them, these are mites that were squashed by the egg in the nest box. This is a bad sign. Having a “crawly” feeling up your arms after an egg collection is another bad sign. It means that mites have crawled up your hands and arms while you were collecting eggs. Roost mites aren’t dangerous to humans, so far as I know, but it’s a very disgusting feeling.

The best early warning sign of mites is to flip the roosts over and look at the undersides. If there are lots of tiny little bugs crawling around there, this is bad.

Because roost mites don’t actually live on the chickens, they’re controlled largely by treating the houses and the nest boxes. There are a variety of treatments. The one that has worked best for me is to paint the undersides of the roosts with linseed oil (which smells good) or the more traditional used motor oil thinned with kerosene (which smells less good). Mites are killed by oils because a film of oil blocks their breathing pores and suffocates them. Probably any non-drying oil would work, though petroleum-based oils have the advantage of not being edible by pests. Mineral oil would probably be okay for people looking for organic certification.

My roosts are not nailed down. I can flip them over, paint them, and flip them back. By painting the undersides only, the birds’ bodies and feathers don’t come into contact with the oil.  (This is why I don’t mind using old motor oil.)

Insecticides also work against roost mites. Malathion and pyrethrins both work and are relatively non-toxic to the birds and humans. They also break down fairly quickly. Sevin works, but you’re not supposed to use it around eggs. As always with chemicals, read the label and follow the directions. (Different insecticides are legal or illegal in different countries, with little rhyme or reason that I can see. Follow local regulations, or at least be furtive.)

You can also kill the mites with steam or boiling water, which would be convenient if you have a hot-water pressure-cleaner handy. Whitewash is supposed to be reasonably effective, but most of the old-time poultry whitewashes had their effectiveness goosed up by chemicals which are banned nowadays for being carcinogenic. Whether plain whitewash is worth the effort is something I don’t know.

Some people will tell you that you can prevent roost mites by providing dust baths, using cedar shavings as nest litter, and putting diatomaceous earth in the nest boxes, dust baths, and everywhere else you can think of. I tried this. Hens died while I was messing around with these half-measures. Then I got out my sprayer and applied about twenty cents’ worth of Malathion to my henhouses. That worked..

Prevention is not cure. Once you have a serious infestation,  you need to kill off the mites now.

See also my article on roost mites.

Coccidiosis

See the discussions  under How Coccidiosis Makes Your Chickens Sick and Baby Chick Care.

Worms

We’ve never had a worm problem. Free range is like that. Karen butchered many thousands of broilers and hens and sometimes opened their intestines to see if there was anything there that shouldn’t be. Nope.

That doesn’t mean that you won’t have a worm problem. It’s an issue with barren yards and confinement. But I don’t know much about it.

Feather Loss

Mysterious feather loss is usually caused by molting or, if it’s concentrated on the backs of hens, by roosters during mating. It may also be caused by feather lice, but if the feather loss is in the fall or winter, or happens after a stressful event such as running out of feed for a couple of days or being moved to a new farm, it’s probably a molt. Molting is the natural process of replacing old feathers with new ones, and is triggered by stress.

Chickens beat each other up fairly routinely when establishing dominance, and plucking out each other’s tail feathers is one of the more noticeable aspects of this. The dominant chickens have much better-looking tail feathers..

Feather loss accompanied by wounds is likely cannibalism, discussed above.